Module overview
Law and the Human Body investigates legal and ethical problems at the intersection of medicine, biotechnology and the law, particularly the approach of law to questions arising from the biotechnological uses of cadavers, body parts and products of the body. The module provides knowledge and understanding of how law and ethics resolve disputes relating to conflicting claims over ownership of inventions based on human body parts, and the question of entitlement to profits from such inventions; it also examines the legal protections available to a person when separated parts of their body are used without their consent; and the remedies available to living relatives when the dead are mutilated without consent.
Aims and Objectives
Learning Outcomes
Transferable and Generic Skills
Having successfully completed this module you will be able to:
- analyse, interpret and evaluate complex material;
- formulate an effective, comprehensible, reasoned and structured argument;
- effectively communicate and present written arguments supported by appropriate evidence, demonstrating an appreciation of academic integrity.
Knowledge and Understanding
Having successfully completed this module, you will be able to demonstrate knowledge and understanding of:
- the legal difficulties that impair the grant of remedies for non-consensual uses of body parts;
- how the human body and body parts are categorised in law for the purpose of making claims in court in relation to an unauthorised interference;
- the important role of property law and property theory in dealing with problems relating to the human body and body parts;
- the historical and modern uses of the human body and body parts in science and medicine, and the scandals that accompanied pioneering anatomical and pharmaceutical uses of the human body and body parts;
- the laws governing the disposition and exhumation of dead bodies.
Subject Specific Intellectual and Research Skills
Having successfully completed this module you will be able to:
- communicate in writing an understanding of law and the human body, its application to the solution of legal problems and the formulation of effective argument with clear and accurate use of language and legal terminology.
- produce effectively reasoned and structured responses to a given statement or proposition, which are adequately supported by reference to legal authority;
Syllabus
The topics to be considered within the module are, indicatively:
1. Historical and modern uses of the human body and the scandals that followed;
2. Mortuary law and jurisprudence, and the control of burial;
3. Legal nature of burial plots;
4. Exhumation;
5. Difficulties in providing judicial remedies for interference with the human body and body parts;
6. Proprietary approach to the human body and body parts.
Learning and Teaching
Teaching and learning methods
The teaching programme comprises 10 x 2 hour weekly seminars.
Teaching methods include:
- Seminars (two-hour weekly seminars) of tutor led discussion structured around suggested preparation for each session to provide you with knowledge and information and to enable you to be critical about that knowledge and information;
- Pre-prepared questions focused on developing your problem solving skills.
Learning activities include:
- Identifying and locating primary and secondary (including electronic) legal sources relevant to the law and the human body;
- Developing your legal skills in identifying, analysing and synthesising a range of legal materials from legislation, case law, policy documents and academic literature to contemporary debates over the law and the human body;
- Directed reading assisted by reading lists;
- Accessing electronic resources in the form of legislation, journals and case materials;
- Researching sources from primary sources of legislation, case law to secondary sources of books, journals and policy papers;
- Reviewing and critically evaluating complex material;
- Developing knowledge of, and ability to explain orally and in writing, the principles of substantive law and key policy objectives surrounding contemporary issues in law and the human body through seminar preparation and discussion and formative assessment;
- Formulating and presenting, in both oral and written form, comprehensible reasoned and structured critical and evaluative argument through seminar preparation and discussion and formative assessment;
- Tackling and solving factual legal problems;
- Participating in constructive oral group discussion and debate;
- Managing tasks within a given time frame.
Type | Hours |
---|---|
Revision | 30 |
Follow-up work | 18 |
Completion of assessment task | 10 |
Wider reading or practice | 40 |
Seminar | 22 |
Preparation for scheduled sessions | 30 |
Total study time | 150 |
Resources & Reading list
General Resources
Other. A reading list – posted on Blackboard – is provided which includes relevant cases, legislation, journal articles, books chapters, Law Commission reports, policy documents etc. as appropriate.
Other. Primary sources including cases and statutes, and some secondary sources (primarily journal articles) are available in paper and electronic form, the latter through electronic books and legal databases, provided by the library or otherwise publically accessible via the worldwide web.
Textbooks
NWabueze, R.N., (2007). Biotechnology and the Challenge of Property. Ashgate.
Assessment
Formative
This is how we’ll give you feedback as you are learning. It is not a formal test or exam.
Mock Examination
- Assessment Type: Formative
- Feedback: Feedback is provided by the mark awarded supported by written tutor feedback on the School’s formative assessment feedback form. Group feedback (via blackboard and/or in class) is provided, with individual oral tutor feedback provided upon request.
- Final Assessment: No
- Group Work: No
Summative
This is how we’ll formally assess what you have learned in this module.
Method | Percentage contribution |
---|---|
Closed book Examination | 100% |
Referral
This is how we’ll assess you if you don’t meet the criteria to pass this module.
Method | Percentage contribution |
---|---|
Closed book Examination | 100% |
Repeat
An internal repeat is where you take all of your modules again, including any you passed. An external repeat is where you only re-take the modules you failed.
Method | Percentage contribution |
---|---|
Closed book Examination | 100% |
Repeat Information
Repeat type: Internal & External